Skip to main content Skip to secondary navigation
Main content start

The future of social hierarchies

A professor who studies workplace hierarchies and human well-being says that collaboration is key to healthy work environments.
Business people on different sets of white stairs going in different directions
How do power, hierarchy, and social ties shape the ways we cooperate, compete, and negotiate at work? | iStock/IR_Stone

Nir Halevy, an expert on organizational behavior, first grew interested in social hierarchies as a basketball fan. 

He now studies what makes for healthy workplaces. Organizational hierarchies can be beneficial, but can turn toxic. When people have power without status – control but little respect – conflict often follows. Halevy says that collaboration, not competition, is key to employee well-being. “If you care about freedom, seek cooperative environments. They will liberate you,” Halevy tells listeners – and host Russ Altman – on this episode of Stanford Engineering’s The Future of Everything podcast.

Listen on your favorite podcast platform:

Transcript

[00:00:00] Russ Altman: This is Stanford Engineering's The Future of Everything, and I'm your host, Russ Altman. I thought it would be good to briefly revisit the intent of this show since we've been doing it for quite a while. In 2017, when we started this show, we wanted to create a forum for showcasing the passion and the work of my colleagues at Stanford, who are doing amazing research to discover new things to solve problems facing humanity.

[00:00:27] This includes the fields of science, technology, medicine, engineering, law, business, arts and sciences, and humanities. Stanford University and many other universities have a long history of making research discoveries that positively impact big problems facing the public, the country, and the world. And it's these motivated humans who I wanted to showcase to show the problems they're working on, why they're working on it, and what the progress has been.

[00:00:54] In that spirit, I hope you'll walk away from every episode with a deeper understanding of the work that's happening at universities, how we share it, how we think about these problems, why we choose these problems, and what the progress is that we're making in a wide variety of disciplines. We also hope that you'll share this with family, friends, colleagues, so that everybody will have a better understanding of the future of everything.

[00:01:18] Nir Halevy: We need those, kind of, aspects in our lives where we feel included, appreciated, respected. We hear from a lot of CEOs that empowerment solves a lot of problems. We have to add status and recognition- Yeah ... and respect to that. Just giving people more power will not solve our concerns if the power is what liberates them to act on negative feelings.

[00:01:44] Russ Altman: This is Stanford Engineering's The Future of Everything, and I'm your host, Russ Altman. If you're enjoying this show, share it with a friend, family member, or colleague. We'd love to spread word about The Future of Everything. Today, Nir Halevy will tell us that hierarchies and networks are everywhere in our personal and professional life, and it probably pays to pay attention to them and perhaps learn how to influence them just a little. It's The Future of Power and Status. 

[00:02:11] Don't forget that at the end of the episode, I'm gonna ask Nir some quick questions, and he's gonna give me some equally quick answers, and we call that The Future in a Minute. Before we get started, a reminder that if you're enjoying the show, please tell friends, family, and colleagues all about it so that they can join The Future of Everything family.

[00:02:30] We are all aware that as we join any group of people, it becomes clear that there are hierarchies, people in charge, people who have the most influence, and there's status, which is who is the most respected, who is listened to. Sometimes the most powerful people have the most status, but not always. We also have social networks that are a little flatter, where it's not a hierarchy, but even then, certain people emerge either because of a granted authority of some kind or because they kind of take authority or the, they're the loudest person in the room. For many reasons, people can emerge as leaders in a, in a group of people, and they also have to think about, and the whole group has to think about, who is the respected voices among the group? 

[00:03:18] Well, Nir Halevy is a professor of organizational behavior at Stanford University's School of Business, and an expert on social networks and social hierarchies, especially in the workplace. He'll tell us that these are things that you need to recognize and carefully try to maybe influence. If you're the leader of a group, you need to pay special attention to them because it can go very wrong. 

[00:03:42] Nir, thanks for joining us. And let me start out, how did you decide to focus your research on social hierarchies and social networks, especially with a focus on the workplace?

[00:03:52] Nir Halevy: Thank you for the opportunity to have a conversation about this, Russ. I think that from a very young age, I was really curious with social dynamics, just observing what's happening on the schoolyard and in my basketball team when I was in high school and things like that, just, right, you see someone being very dominant, and everyone's attention is gravitating towards that person. And they have, a kind of sway that others don't have on the team. And so, I was observing and monitoring. 

[00:04:17] And when I got to, the first year in, psychology undergrad, I was fascinated by the classic experiments, right? So, Milgram and Zimbardo and all of this kind of; and in my mind, I categorized all of these experiments as inherently focusing on social influence, right? So, some of them were about conformity, the Asch experiment. Some of them were about compliance. But in my mind, it's all part of the same broad category of how do we engage with other people to connect with them and influence them. 

[00:04:43] And so, when I started kind of thinking more deeply about research questions, I realized I can study social influence in negotiations and in hierarchies and in social networks. And I tried to seize a lot of different opportunities to study these questions. Our current project, for example, is, looking at social influence in the context of wedding planners, right? So, a lot of people think that, when you, Russ, hire a wedding planner, it's about the DJ and the venue and the caterer. Turns out that it's about helping manage your relationship with your in-laws or future in-laws, if this is before the wedding, right? 

[00:05:14] So it's, it's really fascinating how many intricate dynamics exist when you think about social influence within families and professions. 

[00:05:21] Russ Altman: So, you could not have hit a nerve any harder. I have two of my children are getting married within six weeks- 

[00:05:30] Nir Halevy: Congrats 

[00:05:30] Russ Altman: ... next summer. And so, everything you've said, I, we love our future in-laws, all of them. But you're right that that is a, a, a dynamic that I am beginning to perceive. 

[00:05:40] So, but getting back to the issue at hand, you said the word hierarchies, and I know a lot of your work talks about that. So, I think people have a rough idea that there's a boss at the top, and then there's a, like a pyramid underneath. But I think it would be useful to have a little bit of a definition of what do you mean by hierarchy? And especially I'm, I'm interested in the difference between a hierarchy that's pre-established, like there's a CEO and then there's the C-suite, and then there's the workers, versus a hierarchy that emerges perhaps on a basketball team, for example. So, tell me about hierarchies for a while. 

[00:06:12] Nir Halevy: Definitely. So, a hierarchy is a system, social or organizational, that differentiates between those who have more and those who have less. And the dimensions on which we differentiate can be ability and achievement, but it can also be wealth, status, the number of friends or followers you have on social media, and so on, right? And usually those who have more are in a better position to influence those who have less, right? So, if you have more connections, you're, better able to help your graduate students land jobs when they get their PhDs and so on. 

[00:06:43] When we think about informal hierarchies, we think about those dynamics that emerge organically because someone is taking more space in conversation or someone brings to the front a lot of confidence or even overconfidence. And we know from research done across the bay by Cameron Anderson, our friend at Berkeley, for example, that people confuse confidence with competence. So, when you show a lot of, you project a lot of confidence, people think you're very competent and so on. 

[00:07:06] But you're totally right. There are also more structural role-based hierarchies where we might say, well, if you're middle management, you know that you have subordinates reporting to you, and you know you're accountable to people in top management. And I think these are the structures that, we're hearing a lot of conversations right now given the AI revolution. Can we cut middle management? Are those the role holders, the positions that we wanna kind of get rid of in order to create flat hierarchies, potentially more kind of flat structures? And, and both exist, right?

[00:07:33] Even in those organizations who pretend or claim to be, relatively flat in terms of their organizational structure, you would still see the informal hierarchies. So, Russ, if you worked for a design organization and recently you had tremendous success with a project and the clients loved you, you will have more to say, you will have more voice in our next meeting because we all look up to you and respect you and admire your success.

[00:07:56] Russ Altman: So, you talk about hierarchies and, and, and you've written that they're ubiquitous, which you just described. They're everywhere. They're diverse, and you, you talked about organizational versus kind of emergent. And then you said they're sticky, and the sticky is the part that I was very interested. So, in what sense are hierarchies sticky? Does that mean once you've established it, it's gonna be hard to change it? 

[00:08:18] Nir Halevy: So, they're, malleable to some degree, and we can talk about instability in hierarchies, and there can be changes, and there can be status shocks, right? So maybe if someone, senior just, was fired, right? We just, saw in the news that several members of OpenAI were dismissed recently, right? So, there will be shifts in terms of, the people's kind of where they stand, or there might be even structural changes in organization. 

[00:08:40] But let me go back to the definition or my definition of sticky. I think it's very difficult to undo hierarchy because of two categories of consequences. One is positive consequences or positive forces, right? A hierarchy creates, a sense of predictability, a sense of coordination. I know what to expect, right? In terms of accountability structures, in terms, terms of my responsibility to people that I'm leading.

[00:09:03] It also helps people fulfill fundamental needs for achievement, right? If you wanna get ahead and you know that you have done, great work and we're a meritocratic organization, you will be promoted based on your accomplishments.

[00:09:15] So, there's definitely positive forces, both in terms of fulfilling individual needs but also promoting team success. One of my earlier projects was in the context of professional basketball. So, teams in the NBA win more games in a season when they have a well-functioning hierarchy because it helps coordination. They have more assists. They have fewer turnovers. Really metrics of performance we can measure and, and document. 

[00:09:37] But there, there are also negative forces that lead to the stickiness of hierarchy, right? So, you have people at the top who really enjoy the privileges and advantages they're getting, and they will take actions to stay at the top and maybe even undermine if they're dominant power-seeking leaders. They will undermine other people who are trying to challenge them potentially. 

[00:09:56] We can also think about ideologies that tend to perpetuate hierarchies. And if you're in an environment where hierarchy seems like the moral thing because authority is an important kind of moral imperative from your perspective, then you will say, "Well, I should not challenge hierarchy. I should not try to change it." So, we have both positive and negative forces contributing to the stickiness of hierarchy. 

[00:10:15] Russ Altman: That's really helpful. And, and you just at the, at the end of your answer you said a, you said something that I wanted to ask you about, which is that people at the top of the hierarchy will sometimes take steps to maintain the status quo because it's, it's a good life for them. And I'm wondering, what kind of advice do you give to career people like we're, now we're talking about the workplace, about of, I'm guessing that you're recommending that they understand what the hierarchy is, and sometime it might be implicit, so it takes some observation and some kind of inference about where the real power is.

[00:10:44] But how much do you recommend that people try to manipulate that? Or is that playing with fire and dynamite? 

[00:10:50] Nir Halevy: It's a great question. So, some people are actually advising young people, Gen Z, or people kind of lower in the organizational hierarchy to try to navigate, the hierarchy or manipulate the hierarchy. And some of the advice that I'm hearing is actually very Machiavellian, right? 

[00:11:04] Russ Altman: Yeah. 

[00:11:04] Nir Halevy: So, get the information you're not supposed to get, maybe stab people in the back, make them look bad because it's all relative comparison, and so on. What I would like to encourage, young people and people at the bottom of the hierarchy to do is to figure out multiple pathways to ascend and lead in ways that fit their values and fit the principles that they wanna live by.

[00:11:23] And let me refer here to an example, from research done by our colleague at Stanford, Arvind Karunakaran. He's done this really great research with 911 dispatchers 911 dispatchers sometimes don't get respect from police officers. They are not sworn officers. They don't wear a uniform, and some police officers treat them as just like desk people who don't do important work.

[00:11:43] Obviously, when you call 911, Russ, you hope that they are able to- Yes ... tell the police officer to show up, right? It's, otherwise, we have a big problem. So, let's think about the 911 dispatcher who's on the radio talking to a police officer and trying to tell them, "Go help people. Are you clear from your last job?

[00:11:58] Can I send you to someplace new?" But that person is not responding, right? The dispatcher can say, "Well, I will do all of your paperwork for you for a week. Please go help these people." 

[00:12:07] Russ Altman: Right. 

[00:12:07] Nir Halevy: Or they can say, "I will report you. You will be punished because you're supposed to go help people." But instead, what Arvin kind of documented is they use humor.

[00:12:14] They use appropriate humor on the radio where other police officers can hear them and join the conversation. Huh. So, for example, they would say, "Oh, I see you're parked outside a casino, and someone just won lots of money there. Why don't you go in if you have so much spare time, officer, and gamble?" And then other police officers join, and they say, "Oh, he does have a poker face, and he used to be a dealer way back." and right, they're just joking on the radio. And that actually makes the police officer say, "Okay, dispatch, what do you have for me?" And the dispatch says, "There has been a traffic accident. Go help these people." Right? 

[00:12:45] So, appropriate humor is a way to influence from the bottom up in a way that's helpful, compelling, gets the job done, right? The police officer's now going to go help people, and you didn't undermine anyone. You didn't unravel- 

[00:12:59] Russ Altman: Right 

[00:12:59] Nir Halevy: ... relationships. it's a very constructive way of doing it. 

[00:13:01] Russ Altman: So that is a great example, and that's very positive. And I'm gonna go a little bit negative 'cause you wrote this paper talking about power without status. And then you talked about very scary things about mistreatment and dysfunction, and I wanted you to tell that story and connect those ideas because, you know, it takes a while to understand what power without status even means. So, maybe you can help us by understand what that is and then show us what the consequences are and where that all comes from. 

[00:13:27] Nir Halevy: Definitely. Let's define power and status. Yeah. So power is control over valuable resources, personnel, budgets, decision-making authority. 

[00:13:35] Russ Altman: Okay. 

[00:13:35] Nir Halevy: Status is the respect and admiration you have in the eyes of others, right? 

[00:13:38] So, let's give examples from our context, from academia, right? So, John Levin, the president of Stanford University, has power and status. He's held in high regard, and he's controlling budgets and personnel and so on. 

[00:13:49] We can think about an emeritus professor, maybe a Nobel laureate who retired 20 years ago. Brilliant person, will give you great advice, has a lot of respect and admiration in the eyes of people. Maybe they're not controlling budgets and personnel and so on, right? 

[00:14:02] Russ Altman: Yes. 

[00:14:02] Nir Halevy: They've been retired for 20 years and so on. They establish- 

[00:14:04] Russ Altman: So, we would call that high status but questionable power. 

[00:14:07] Nir Halevy: Correct. You can think about the cleaning crews that come and clean our buildings at night, and sometimes, unfortunately for me, I'm, sometimes here at 10:00 PM in the office, and I get to kind of see. And, and they're making it amazingly beautiful and brilliant when we show up in the morning. Everything is, in its place and clean and ready to, to do work.

[00:14:25] But they're not very prominent and salient to people, right? In organizations, they might not have, high power and high status in the way we just defined them. And that's, then let's think about the specific quadrant that you asked about. 

[00:14:36] Russ Altman: Yeah. 

[00:14:36] Nir Halevy: Kind of power without status. So, let's say, Russ, you traveled for work and you incurred certain costs, and you need to get $12,000 back in reimbursements. But the reimbursement-

[00:14:46] Russ Altman: It was a good trip. A good trip. 

[00:14:47] Nir Halevy: Awesome trip. Then the reimbursement person tells you, "Russ, I do not appreciate the tone of your voice. The way you ask me for help, I don't like it. Come back in 2028." Right? 

[00:14:58] And so, that would happen based on our research because they often do not feel appreciated or respected in the way people- Ah engage with them and interact with them. In that specific context where you need their help to get your reimbursement, they have power. They control something that you need. Budgets, right? Access to those funds. We can think about other roles in organizations that have the same characteristics, right?

[00:15:19] Think about TSA security officers in the airport. Ah. Right? So, people might tell them, "Can you hurry up? I'm gonna be late to my flight They are not very often hearing words such as, "Sir, ma'am, thank you so much for your service. We appreciate you. Thank you for keeping us safe." Right? 

[00:15:36] And so, what we discovered, both in lab experiments and in the field, that, is that when people are occupying these positions that involve low status, they have negative feelings. People don't appreciate, don't respect what they do. But when they have power, they are liberated to act on these negative feelings. And this really toxic combination of having negative feelings and being liberated to act on it creates dysfunctional conflict in organizations.

[00:15:59] I'll just kind of share with you that we found it in the context of the federal government, here in the US. at some point, they decided to reduce their real estate footprint. They moved really powerful people who have a direct line to the White House to a hot desk system. They don't have their corner office anymore. Ah, ah. They don't have their entire team sitting outside their suite. They don't have their par- private parking. And so, people could respond, in theory, with very benign actions. You could turn your email signature from 3 lines to 15 lines to remind everyone how powerful you are. 

[00:16:29] Russ Altman: Right, right. 

[00:16:29] Nir Halevy: But what happened there is they actually started being demeaning and domineering to others, and they are abused their power in a way that was dysfunctional and created interpersonal conflict.

[00:16:39] Russ Altman: So, this is amazing. And if I'm now a CEO or a leader, I feel like you've, you've just given me a to-do item, which is to examine my organization and look for the sources of power and make sure that there is some consideration of establishing a status for those folks so that they feel well-served and so that they don't start harboring kind of negative attitudes to. I mean, it's a very understandable response that you just described, and you might hope that higher values like understanding the mission of the organization, the limited resources, we did this because. But but you can also understand why people have trouble endorsing all of that. And so, it sounds like it, it creates a to-do for management to be aware of these potentials and to kind of try to mitigate them. 

[00:17:24] Nir Halevy: Definitely. And there's a lot we can do to actually increase the sense of respect people get.

[00:17:28] Let me share with you another example that I think is fascinating. Televerde is a business-to-business marketing company. It has a unique model where they operate from within prisons. They have inmates working for the company. Now let's think about the context of a prison, right? So, the treatment that the inmates are receiving in the prison yard and in interactions with the prison guards might not involve a lot of respect on a daily basis.

[00:17:51] Russ Altman: Right, right. 

[00:17:51] Nir Halevy: But what they're getting from their employers in the company is not just an opportunity to be a meaningful contributor to generating revenue and being in touch with the external world as an employee of Televerde from within the prison. It's a lot of respect, right? 

[00:18:03] And quotes in research done by our colleagues, show that really that's the sense that they're getting, that they're being respected. Respected as humans who deserve dignity and respect just for being humans but also individualized respect because they have contributed meaningfully to achieving the mission of the company. 

[00:18:20] Russ Altman: So now you're partitioning the world where they have part of their life where they're getting respect, and that might actually spill over into their attitude towards how much they're irritated by their treatment by the prison guards.

[00:18:32] Is that I'm, I just wanna make sure I'm following, is that they might actually have a little bit more centered self kind of worth so that when the prison guards do whatever they do, they can kind of take a deep breath and say, "All right, you know, whatever. I'm gonna now go to my job where I'm getting some respect, and I can deal with this guy for now."

[00:18:49] Nir Halevy: I think it's so important that people have areas in their lives where they're getting that respect, right? I'm gonna connect it to research done years ago by Claude Steele, another colleague of ours here at Stanford- 

[00:18:58] Russ Altman: Yes 

[00:18:58] Nir Halevy: ... right, about self-affirmation, right? We need those aspects in our lives where we feel included, appreciated, respected.

[00:19:05] And let me just connect it to our conversation about the CEO and what they need to do tomorrow morning, right? We hear from a lot of CEOs that empowerment solves a lot of problems. We have to add status and recognition- 

[00:19:15] Russ Altman: Yes 

[00:19:15] Nir Halevy: ... and respect to that, right? Just giving people more power will not, solve our, concerns if the power is the, what liberates them to act on negative feelings.

[00:19:24] Russ Altman: This is The Future of Everything, and I'm Russ Altman. I'm speaking with Nir Halevy from Stanford University. We've been discussing hierarchies, social networks, and how to navigate in the workplace and in other places the human relationships that emerge that may not be totally equal and lead to differences in power and status, for example. We're gonna move the discussion to, a few topics on autonomy and its importance or lack of importance, secrets at work, and maybe a little bit about how all of this can affect your well-being. 

[00:19:53] Before we do that, please stick around for the Future in a Minute. At the end of the interview, I'm gonna ask Nir some questions. He's gonna give me some quick answers, and that'll be the Future in a Minute. So Nir, you've written about autonomy and its importance. How does that relate to some of the concepts we've been talking in the, in the earlier part of the conversation? 

[00:20:10] Nir Halevy: So, I think that one of the main motivations of HR leaders, but also top management teams in general to kind of try to flatten organizational hierarchies is to give people this sense of greater freedom. We know freedom is an important motivation. One of the most influential theories of the last fifty years in motivation, self-determination theory, tells us that people wanna have autonomy, they wanna have, feel competent, and they wanna have relatedness fulfilled, in the workplace. 

[00:20:34] And autonomy is kind of even more primary than the other two because once you have autonomy, you can craft your own job, you can kind of modify your environment to get- 

[00:20:42] Russ Altman: Right

[00:20:42] Nir Halevy: competence, to get relatedness. And so, we were curious. it turns out that most research over the last 50 years from the perspective of self-determination theory has not looked at how two really fundamental forces in terms of social interactions at work, cooperation and competition, shape your feelings of autonomy at work.

[00:20:59] And there's a reason to think that both might actually contribute in different ways to autonomy. For example, if there is a lot of competition, you might feel, well, the end justifies the means. I can compete in a number of different ways, right? So, there is a liberating force potentially in competition.

[00:21:14] But also cooperation brings with it certain experiences, we would say, right? Like it reduces a sense of threat. You are not feeling you're, you're going to be undermined by your colleagues. It's not a very kind of sabotage or undermining type environment.

[00:21:28] Russ Altman: Right. 

[00:21:28] Nir Halevy: And so, maybe that actually helps with autonomy. You're not experiencing stress as much in this environment, and maybe that can help with autonomy. 

[00:21:35] So we've done this research with athletes, in, college. We've done this research with an archival dataset from the federal government. We've done this in a lot of different contexts, even in kind of very carefully controlled decision-making experiments. And turns out that if you give people the exact same set of choices, but you're framing it in a cooperative way rather than in a competitive way, you're getting higher levels of autonomy So I could show you a set of choices that has just- 

[00:22:00] Russ Altman: Wow 

[00:22:00] Nir Halevy: ... like three choices, but you think that by coordinating your choices with someone else, you're going to get a bonus, or you have to be mis coordinated with them to receive your bonus, and then they lose and you win. Turns out in the first situation, where it's a win-win situation, you're going to experience more autonomy, more intrinsic motivation. 

[00:22:18] And when we looked at in the context of federal employees in a large data set, turns out it predicts a lot of positive downstream consequences, right? 

[00:22:25] Russ Altman: Yeah. This is really interesting 'cause even in our field, you know, we're academics, and we have to make choices between do we collaborate with other scientists or scholars, or do we go alone with our own lab? And, sometimes you think, "Well, this is such a good idea. Maybe I better keep it to myself, not really share it." 

[00:22:42] It, it is amazing because it's, it's easy for me to believe that autonomy would sometimes be preferable to, competition. But it sounds like your findings are even stronger than that, is that you were seeing systematically that a cooperative approach might lead to a better sense of autonomy, and then you get all those benefits that you described earlier from your autonomy and its positive effects.

[00:23:04] Nir Halevy: Right. So, you get more attention, less turnover, more engagement at work and so on. And the mechanism is really psychological safety, right? It's a construct- 

[00:23:11] Russ Altman: Yeah 

[00:23:11] Nir Halevy: ... that Amy Edmondson introduced to the literature years ago. And if you think about a very cutthroat environment, it can be in finance, it can be in tech, it can be in a lot of different contexts. It's not conducive for people staying long-term. It's not constructive in terms of people's ability to fulfill fundamental needs. 

[00:23:26] Russ Altman: So, speaking about the dark side, you, you also write about secrets and secrets at work. And who doesn't love how spicy that sounds? So, tell us about the work on secrets and, and how it relates.

[00:23:38] Nir Halevy: So, when we start thinking about different professions, right? You can think about law enforcement. You can think about engineers working in new product development. So, let's think about some Silicon Valley companies, and we will not name names, but some of them are very secretive, right? You, you might not be able to share in the cafeteria what you're working on, even with a colleague that has been your colleague for 20 years, right?

[00:23:57] Russ Altman: Right. Right. 

[00:23:58] Nir Halevy: And so, turns out that that actually, produces two effects simultaneously the first effect is that it increases stress because it makes you lonely, right? So, we connect with other people by sharing with them, right? 

[00:24:09] Russ Altman: Okay. 

[00:24:09] Nir Halevy: We tell them what we do at work, we tell them. But if you're a psychologist or a medical doctor, in other professions where you're not allowed to talk about your patients or projects or new product, you might not have this benefit of connecting with people by talking about what you do at work, right?

[00:24:23] Russ Altman: Yes, yes. 

[00:24:23] Nir Halevy: So, that's one effect of secrets in organizations. 

[00:24:25] The other effect is because you're given privileged access to information, you feel like you have higher status. 

[00:24:32] Russ Altman: Yes. 

[00:24:32] Nir Halevy: And then you feel that your work is more meaningful, right? "Oh, I'm working on something that's so important that it has to be kept a secret," right?

[00:24:40] Russ Altman: Right. 

[00:24:40] Nir Halevy: And so, we have this kind of dual path where on the one hand it undermines, secrets at work undermine your hedonic wellbeing. It reduces positive feelings, it increases stress. But simultaneously it enhances your demonic wellbeing. It makes work more meaningful, more purposeful, right? And so, 

[00:24:58] Russ Altman: Yeah

[00:24:58] Nir Halevy: I think leaders need to be aware of this trade-off, right? You're making people lonely and stressed, but you're making the work look more meaningful. 

[00:25:04] Russ Altman: So, it, it's great. This, I'm really glad I asked this question because it's not that it's a simple good or a simple bad. There's a knob there and, and you need to think about where you wanna set that knob. It probably means you don't want everything to be a secret maybe. I'm just making this up. On the other hand, having a few secrets might be just what the doctor ordered, so to speak, for the wellbeing and, and the general outlook of the employee. 

[00:25:30] Nir Halevy: And, and I think there's a, a practical implication in the notion that you need to provide social support to your employees.

[00:25:36] So, you don't want them to share the secret formula for Coca-Cola with other people necessarily. 

[00:25:40] Russ Altman: Right. 

[00:25:40] Nir Halevy: But maybe even just coming together and being able to commiserate with others who have to also keep secrets, or just, like, understanding that we're all in this together to serve the greater good of the company or the organization, if you think about federal organizations, that there's a purpose to it, right? Social support is so essential, and if people feel lonely, we can help them with that. 

[00:25:59] Russ Altman: And now I'm going back to our power without status. I'm saying maybe those people who have power but not status, you just need to tell them a couple of secrets so that they can elevate their sense of status. 

[00:26:10] Nir Halevy: Right. And- 

[00:26:12] Russ Altman: Okay. Before we finish, in the last few minutes, I want you, you said the word wellbeing a couple of seconds ago, and a, a lot of what we've been talking about boils down to the wellbeing, which of course will translate to the happiness... to, well, includes the happiness and the productivity. So... And I know you've been looking at that explicitly. So, how do you think about wellbeing in the context of hierarchies, networks, and these different dynamics we've been discussing? 

[00:26:36] Nir Halevy: So, to your earlier point that things are complicated, right? We wanna think about three different kind of, dimensions of wellbeing, right? We can think about happiness, we can think about interestingness, and we can think about meaning at work, right?

[00:26:47] Russ Altman: Yes. 

[00:26:47] Nir Halevy: So those are three different kinds of wellbeing, and they're not always perfectly aligned, right? So, you can be exactly happy about what you do at work but feel that it's repetitive and not very interesting and not meaningful. 

[00:26:58] Or you can think that the work is very, very meaningful and not get kind of the, the positive, feelings because you're doing something that's difficult. And we talked earlier, about wedding planners, for example. 

[00:27:09] Russ Altman: Yeah. 

[00:27:09] Nir Halevy: So, let's say that a wedding planner, and that's consistent with our findings, has to navigate a lot of family drama. There are just conflicts between the bride and the groom and between the bride and her mom, and other kind. These are actual data that we have from the wedding planners.

[00:27:23] Turns out that that does two things simultaneously. It increases stress for the wedding planner, so it reduces their hedonic wellbeing, but it makes life more interesting, right? 

[00:27:32] Russ Altman: Right. 

[00:27:32] Nir Halevy: So, there's more drama, there's more, like, interesting. And the meaningfulness piece actually comes from the gratitude that they're getting after the event, right? So, when they see appreciation in online reviews or in thank you notes or in. 

[00:27:44] And, and that takes me actually full circle back to the solutions we might deploy in dysfunctional hierarchies, right, to increase wellbeing. 

[00:27:51] Russ Altman: Yeah. 

[00:27:51] Nir Halevy: Imagine, Russ, that you're getting a gratitude letter from a former student or from a colleague or from someone you mentored or an intern and so on, right? Like, that actually shows that you have impact, positive impact on others, right? That really helps make the work more meaningful. 

[00:28:04] Russ Altman: It's unbelievably impactful when that, when things like that happen. 

[00:28:07] Nir Halevy: Yeah. So, across a number of our current projects and as we're thinking into the future, we're trying to understand how brokering social networks, how different behaviors in negotiation, how different solutions to problem, structural problems in hierarchies, might, help wellbeing. And as you said it, it's not just stopping at wellbeing. There are downstream consequences for retention, for productivity, for engagement. 

[00:28:30] Russ Altman: So, you talked about, I love this triad that you brought up, which was happiness, meaningfulness, and interestingness. But unlike other triads, I'm not hearing you say that you can only have two out of the three. You know, there's a lot of things where they say, "Pick two out of three, but you can't..." 

[00:28:43] But, you're suggesting that it might actually be possible to get all three, and as a leader of an organization, you might be actually looking at your, your fellow workers and thinking, "How are we on these three, and is there, are there bars that I can move or dials I can turn to try to, improve it, all three of those aspects at once?"

[00:29:01] Nir Halevy: Yeah, and I think part of the solution from my perspective at least is pluralism, right? So, let's take to a con- go to a context that I, I find fascinating: elite ballet companies. 

[00:29:09] Russ Altman: Yeah. 

[00:29:09] Nir Halevy: Right? So, one of the things I, I find fascinating is that, going into this research, I thought that technical perfection and maybe a couple more dimensions of evaluations are key, and those are the only metrics that actually, 

[00:29:19] Russ Altman: Right, right

[00:29:20] Nir Halevy: Create value in this context. But I've discovered that there's more than a dozen dimensions that actually matter, right? So maybe- 

[00:29:26] Russ Altman: Wow 

[00:29:26] Nir Halevy: ... Russ, you're the most reliable partner, right? So, when you do the lifts, you're not pushing hard on anyone's ribs, and no one's worried that you might, like, drop them to the floor and cause-

[00:29:34] Russ Altman: Yep

[00:29:34] Nir Halevy: ...an injury, right? So being a reliable partner is a dimension of adding value. 

[00:29:38] We can think about the fact that you have, let's say, half a million followers on social media, and so you bring audiences to come and watch us as a ballet company, right? 

[00:29:45] Russ Altman: Okay. 

[00:29:45] Nir Halevy: That's valuable. 

[00:29:46] Russ Altman: Okay. 

[00:29:46] Nir Halevy: So, I think a leader that adopts a pluralistic mindset can do a lot to support the wellbeing of their followers, of their employees.

[00:29:54] Russ Altman: Well, this is fantastic and thank you so much. But before we end, I wanna ask if you're ready to do our segment that we call The Future in a Minute. 

[00:30:02] Nir Halevy: Ready. 

[00:30:02] Russ Altman: Okay. I'm gonna ask five questions, and then I would love to get your somewhat short answers. 

[00:30:08] Okay, here we go. What is one thing that gives you the most hope for the future?

[00:30:12] Nir Halevy: My children and my students. 

[00:30:13] Russ Altman: What's one thing you want people to walk away from this episode remembering? 

[00:30:17] Nir Halevy: That if you care about freedom, seek cooperative environments. They will liberate you. 

[00:30:22] Russ Altman: Aside from money, what is the one thing you need in your research to succeed? 

[00:30:27] Nir Halevy: Great partners. Thinking partners. 

[00:30:29] Russ Altman: If all goes well, what does the future look like?

[00:30:31] Nir Halevy: Greater, work-life balance for all of us. 

[00:30:34] Russ Altman: And finally, if you were starting over again and you needed to get your degree or certification in a different discipline, what would it be? 

[00:30:42] Nir Halevy: That's a tough one. I would say I would wanna be a sports psychologist, and I would wanna, do a number of things. Maybe I would kind of go into creative writing. So, let's, let's, land on these two, sports psychologist and, an author. 

[00:30:56] Russ Altman: Thanks to Nir Halevy. That was The Future of Power and Status. Thank you also for listening to this show. 

[00:31:02] Don't forget we have a back catalog of almost 350 episodes where you can spend a lot of time listening to the future of just about anything. Also, wanna help shape future episodes? If you leave a review and rating, we will read every comment you make, and we will discuss it at our staff meeting. So, this is a way to affect the future of the show. Please do rate and review. As I always say, we love to get a 5.0 if we deserve it. 

[00:31:30] You can connect with me on many social media platforms, including LinkedIn, Bluesky, Threads, and Mastodon, where I'm @RussBAltman or @RBAltman. You can also connect with the Stanford School of Engineering @StanfordSchoolOfEngineering or @StanfordENG.